Back

Editorial Checklist for AI-Assisted Content in 2025

This checklist sets a clear bar for blogs that use AI during drafting or editing. It guards against low-value mass production and keeps focus on readers. It also reflects current search, legal, and accessibility rules that affect how content is found, trusted, and shared. Google’s March 2024 updates target scaled content abuse, site-reputation abuse, and expired domain abuse, so teams must show clear human value in each post.

Sep 19, 2025

Editorial Checklist for AI-Assisted Content in 2025 - Blog image

Editorial Standards for AI Assistance


AI is a drafting partner, not an author. Each post must have a named human editor who accepts accountability for facts, tone, and claims.


Google’s guidance allows AI-assisted content that meets Search Essentials and avoids scaled content abuse. That places the bar on usefulness, originality, and reliable sourcing.


Set simple rules across the team:


  • Use AI to outline, suggest angles, and compress notes.

  • Do not publish AI output without human rewriting, examples, or data from real work.

  • Keep a prompt log in the CMS entry to show how AI helped.


Research and Fact Verification


Every claim that carries a number, date, or name needs a source. Prefer primary material such as legislation pages, official standards, and first-party datasets. Add the publication date next to time-sensitive facts. This reduces drift when rules change.


Include checks for:


  • Search policy updates that affect content strategy.

  • Accessibility standards that affect UI descriptions and instructions.

  • Regulatory milestones that trigger disclosure or record-keeping.


Examples: Google’s March 2024 anti-spam policies, WCAG 2.2 criteria introduced in 2024, and the EU AI Act timeline entering force in 2025.


Attribution and Citations


Cite sources that a reader can open. Link the exact page. Use neutral verbs such as “states” or “shows.” Do not stack aggregator posts. 


Prefer the primary doc, like Google Search Central, W3C, or an official press release. Google’s own guidance stresses meeting Search Essentials, so a tidy citations section supports that aim.


Disclosure and Provenance


Tell readers when AI helped, in plain text on the page or in an author note. While Google does not require a blanket label, clear disclosure builds trust and aligns with transparency duties that appear in several regimes. 


The EU AI Act includes transparency obligations for AI interactions and deepfakes, and its staged timeline began in 2025. 


Provenance signals such as Content Credentials from the C2PA standard are gaining adoption among major vendors. Where possible, embed or retain these markers in images and downloadable assets.


Practical steps:


  • Add a short “AI assistance” note in the byline block.

  • Keep raw prompts and major AI edits in an internal log.

  • Preserve C2PA metadata on images when tools support it.


Author Credentials and Trust Signals


Readers and search systems look for clear authorship. Add a byline with a real name, an about page, and links to profiles. 


Tie topic experience to the post. This supports expertise and experience signals that help readers decide what to trust. Publish date and “updated on” date must be visible.


AI Originality and Plagiarism Checks


AI detectors vary in accuracy and often flag clean human text. Treat them as diagnostic tools, not gates. A recent community test compared several detectors and showed wide swings across the same sample, including false flags on human work.


The lesson is simple: focus on clear sourcing and human edits, not “beating” a meter.


Use plagiarism checks on quotes and definitions. If a sentence mirrors a source, rewrite it or quote and credit.


SEO Requirements for AI-Content 2025


Search updates since 2024 target low-value mass production. Blogs must show unique insight, testing, or data. Avoid scaled page factories and reputation piggybacking. Publish fewer, stronger posts with clear evidence.


On-page standards:


  • One primary intent per URL.

  • Clear title that names the benefit, not a vague slogan.

  • Intro that sets scope in under 80 words.

  • Subheads that map to questions a reader would ask.

  • Concise meta description that matches the on-page promise.

  • Internal links to related posts and external links to primary sources.


If AI helped draft text, the final copy must add original analysis, examples, or results. Google’s page on using generative AI repeats this point and ties it to Search Essentials.


Watch SERP features. AI Overviews can reduce click-through for generic queries. Compete with depth, unique formats, and original research that is hard to paraphrase. 


Recent coverage shows rising friction between publishers and AI summary features, which makes defensible, cited work even more important.


Readability and Tone


Write for a human on a screen, not for a detector. Use short and medium sentences. Keep one idea per line. 


Avoid filler and stock phrases. Replace abstractions with concrete nouns and numbers. Reduce modals. Cut stacked clauses. The goal is plain speech that holds attention and reads fast on mobile.


Accessibility and Inclusive Design


WCAG 2.2 adds nine success criteria with stronger direction for focus states, target size, and help text. Content must describe images, chart trends, and UI steps in words.


 Make alt text specific. Write link text that names the action or page. Avoid images of text. Confirm color contrast for embedded charts and screenshots.


Quick checks:


  • Alt text that states function and key detail.

  • Headings in logical order.

  • Tables with headers, summaries, and no layout misuse.


Legal and Compliance Checks


Claims and endorsements


If a post includes product claims or testimonials, keep records. The U.S. FTC has warned firms about deceptive AI claims and has brought actions when marketing overpromises or hides material facts. Avoid hype. State what was tested and how it was measured.


Copyright and AI-assisted material


In the U.S., the Copyright Office says only human-authored parts qualify for protection. If a post contains AI-generated segments or images, keep drafts and mark what the human changed. This helps with registration and internal review.


Regional transparency rules


For audiences in the EU, track the AI Act schedule. Some transparency duties apply now, while broader rules phase in over the next months and years. Keep a short compliance note in your editorial SOP and revisit it during updates.


Images and Media from Generative Tools


List the tool, seed or settings when relevant, and the human edits. Confirm that licensing covers commercial use. 


Preserve C2PA metadata when available and avoid stripping it during compression. When the image replaces a real person or event, add a visible label to prevent confusion.


Major ecosystem members back Content Credentials, which helps readers trace the file history.


AI Content Publication Workflow


  • Brief Define reader, problem, and the result the post will deliver. Add the single-sentence promise to the CMS.


  • Outline Draft with AI if useful, then reshape by hand. Remove generic filler. Add planned sources.


  • Draft Write new examples, data points, or steps from hands-on work. Mark any unknowns for research.


  • Source pass Verify each claim. Add links and dates. Replace weak sources with primary ones.


  • Edit pass Tighten verbs. Cut soft modals. Remove clichés. Add subheads that match user questions.


  • Compliance pass Review claims, disclosures, and licensing. Add author bio and last-updated date.


  • Accessibility pass Add alt text. Check headings. Check link text and contrast.


  • Final checks Run plagiarism scan. Skim with at least one detector for a directional signal and fix any robotic tone. Do not chase a specific score. The target is clarity, originality, and proof. Community testing shows detectors conflict, so editorial care matters more than a number.


  • Publish and archive Store the prompt log, sources, and major edits with the article record.


Tools That Support Editorial Checks

Manual reviews remain the backbone of quality control, but tools can help speed up passes without replacing human judgment. 


Grammar and readability checkers highlight weak sentences, while plagiarism scanners flag borrowed text. AI-humanizing platforms refine tone and reduce the risk of false flags from detectors.


Rephrasy, for example, can assist in smoothing phrasing, cutting robotic patterns, and aligning drafts with natural cadence before final publication. 


When paired with human editing, it becomes a practical step in the editorial workflow, helping teams publish content that is both authentic and reader-friendly.


AI Content Post-Publication Monitoring


Look at engagement and search queries weekly for new posts, then monthly. Add fresh data, screenshots, and citations when rules or interfaces change. 


Google’s anti-spam work continues to evolve, so watch for policy updates and adjust templates and playbooks. Google for Developers


Track:

  • Queries that hit your post but bounce fast.

  • Questions in comments that call for a new subhead.

  • Policy or standards updates that affect claims.


Quick Editorial Checklist for AI-Assisted Blog Posts


Here is a quick, handy checklist to follow or print to make sure all factors are incorporated in your AI content.


Category

Checklist Items

Story and Scope

Define a clear reader and promise in the brief

Provide an original angle, example, or dataset

Research and Sources

Link to primary sources with dates

Verify and label all numbers

Check quotes and trace them to origin

AI Assistance

Add a disclosure line about AI support

Store the prompt log with the post

Assign a human editor as accountable

SEO and Structure

Use a specific title and concise intro

Write subheads that answer user questions

Add internal links to related posts

Add external links to primary sources

Create a meta description that mirrors the page promise

Readability

Use short and medium sentences

Remove filler and stock phrases

Prefer precise verbs and concrete nouns

Accessibility

Write alt text for all images

Keep headings in logical order

Use descriptive link text

Check contrast in charts and UI shots

Compliance

Support claims with tests or data

Clarify copyright status of AI-assisted parts

Verify licensing for images and quotes

Apply regional transparency notes where needed

Final Checks

Pass a plagiarism scan

Skim with AI detectors and apply editorial judgment

Include an author bio

Publish and archive sources


Get Started Now

Humanize AI Text to Craft Content at Scale

Revolutionizing AI Paraphrasing